Need help from experieced teachers!!!!!!?

Has he been tested, or is your school just letting him slip through the cracks? It looks as though he likes history and geography and doesn't do well in math or science, in which he could have a disability. He's getting too big to be held back. Some states don't allow kids to be held back more than once in one grade. I'd pass him and get him some testing. If he's doing good work it could also be that he doesn't test well and could be eligible for extra time on exams. It sounds like the school is failing him rather than the other way around.